ABSTRACT
Objective
This study was conducted to molecularly identify and classify Cryptosporidium spp. in fecal samples (n=150) from patients with diarrhea received at the microbiology laboratory of a private hospital in Denizli.
Methods
In this study, the positivity of Cryptosporidium spp. in fecal samples was investigated using direct microscopy, Kinyoun’s acid-fast staining method, and Nested polymerase chain reaction (PCR) techniques. Positive PCR products were sequenced.
Results
In the examined fecal samples of patients with diarrhea, no parasites were detected through direct microscopic examination. Using the Kinyoun acid-fast staining method, Cryptosporidium spp. was identified in 2.7% (n=4) of the samples, while Nested PCR detected it in 4.67% (n=7) of the samples. The four positive samples were sequenced using primers that amplify the 18S rRNA gene region. The sequencing results identified the isolates as C. parvum.
Conclusion
Cryptosporidiosis is an important public health issue as it is a zoonotic disease caused by the Cryptosporidium parasite that can be transmitted from animals to humans. This study focuses on the molecular characterization of Cryptosporidium species detected in human fecal samples, which is significant for understanding which specific strains or species are involved in human infections. According to the findings, it is recommended that control measures be implemented to reduce the risk of exposure to Cryptosporidium in both humans and animals in Türkiye.
INTRODUCTION
Cryptosporidiosis, is the name given to a wide range of diseases caused by Cryptosporidium spp. species, which have different genetic characteristics, from non-symptomatic infections to acute enteric diseases in animals and humans (1-3). Cryptosporidium spp. is widespread throughout the world, including in underdeveloped countries, rural areas of developed countries or urban centers (4-6). This prevalence, has been reported to be detected at rates ranging from 0.7 to 20% in more than 40 countries in the world; it has been observed that it is higher in developing or underdeveloped countries where sanitation measures are not taken and social and personal cleaning is not fully implemented (7-9).
By amplifying specific gene regions using molecular methods, more information was obtained about the transmission routes, species-specific data and biological characteristics of Cryptosporidium species (8).
Of the two different genotypes responsible for human cryptosporidiosis; it has been determined that the human genotype (I) is found only in humans while the bovine genotype (II) can cause infection in humans, sheep, cattle, deer, rarely pigs and mice. Genotype II has been reported to constitute the majority of human infections (3, 10). The type I genotype responsible for human infection was determined to be C. hominis (previously called type I of C. parvum or the human genotype of C. parvum) and the type II genotype (previously named type II or bovine genotype) was C. parvum. It has been reported that C. hominis has very high host specificity and very low genetic variation while C. parvum has very low host specificity and very high genetic variation (1, 5, 8, 11, 12). The fact that C. parvum unlike C. hominis can infect not only humans, but also domestic and wild ruminants and rodents, proves that it is a zoonotic species (1). Although C. parvum with the zoonotic character and C. hominis with the anthroponotic character are the most common causes of cryptosporidiosis in humans (5), cases of C. muris, C. meleagridis, C. suis, C. canis and C. felis have also been reported to cause infections in humans (4, 10, 13). Cryptosporidium parvum species plays a dominant role especially in zoonotic cryptosporidiosis in humans (14).
The incubation period of cryptosporidiosis generally ranges from 5-28 days (7, 15). Diarrhea is the most important clinical manifestation of the disease in both immunologically intact and suppressed individuals. Less frequently, patients also experience abdominal pain, fever, nausea-vomiting and weight loss (15). Resistant oocysts excreted in the feces of infective hosts are the route of transmission. Livestock especially calves and other domestic animals play a major role in human transmission (15). Human-to-human transmission is also possible. Human-to-human contamination can occur via fecal-oral route (15, 16). Human-to-human infections were first seen in kindergartens (17). Epidemics, especially seen in child care homes and hospitals, are the biggest indicator that proves the importance of transmission between people. Today, Cryptosporidium is also known as the causative agent of tourist disease (15, 18). Travels from developed countries to less developed countries also contribute to the spread of Cryptosporidium. It is known that cryptosporidiosis is transmitted homosexually among HIV-positive patients (17).
In epidemics, water is also shown as a source. The high rate of Cryptosporidium in spring and surface waters, the resistance of oocysts to disinfectants such as chlorine, the ability to pass through the filters of drinking water treatment networks and the very few oocysts that cause infection cause water-borne epidemics (1, 14-16).
It is known that cryptosporidiosis, like all parasitic diseases, poses a major public health problem and causes economic losses. Due to the long duration of the treatment and the high cost of treatment, it is necessary to pay attention to the prevention of the disease (7). Since there is no effective treatment against this parasite yet, the infection in patients can become chronic and life-threatening. Since the basic biology of Cryptosporidium is not fully understood, an effective treatment method against the disease has not been determined (1, 7).
Except for a few studies with small sample sizes, little is known about the molecular characterization of human Cryptosporidium species in Türkiye. Therefore, our study, aimed at molecular identification and characterization of the Cryptosporidium spp. species in diarrheal human stools.
METHODS
Sampling and Identification of Cryptosporidium Oocysts
A total of 150 stool samples (69/F, 81/M) collected from individuals aged 0-87 who presented to a private hospital in Denizli were examined for Cryptosporidium. In the analysis of the collected samples, only “age and sex” data were considered
(Table 1).
All samples were stored at 4 °C until microscopic examination and DNA extraction. The samples were examined parasitologically by the native-Lugol direct examination method. Then, some feces were taken from the samples and subjected to formol-ethyl acetate precipitation and preparation processes. All samples were stained with Kinyoun’s acid-fast staining method and examined microscopically.
The study was approved by the Ethical Committee of Kütahya Health Sciences University (09.02.2021/2021/02-16).
Genomic DNA Isolation
At this stage, 200 µL of each of the thoroughly homogenized stool samples was taken and DNA extraction was performed in accordance with the “Thermo Scientific GeneJETTM” DNA Purification Kit procedure. The obtained DNAs were stored at -20 °C for use in the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) process.
SSU rRNA Nested PCR
Primer sets (Crypto F1 and Crypto R1) targeting a 1325bp region of the SSU-rRNA region and used in previous studies were preferred in PCR applications (19-21). In the first step of PCR, primers Crypto F1 (PCR Forward Primer) and Crypto R1 (PCR Reverse Primer) were used, which amplify a 1325bp DNA fragment from the SSU rRNA encoding DNA region of Cryptosporidium species. With the help of the methods used in previous studies, the Nested-PCR reaction was performed using Crypto F2 (Nested PCR Forward Primer) and Crypto R2 (Nested PCR Reverse Primer) primers, which amplify a region of 826-864bp (Table 2) (19-21). In order to detect amplicons obtained from genomic DNAs that underwent PCR and Nested PCR procedures, they were subjected to electrophoresis on a 1% agarose gel and visualized.
Sequence Analysis of SSU rRNA
Agarose gel electrophoresis was performed to detect the sequences obtained from genomic DNAs that underwent PCR and Nested PCR procedures. The specific bands obtained after the imaging process were cut from the gel and purified. During the purification process, the Gene Jet Purification Kit procedure was followed.
Sequence analysis was performed by a commercial firm. The data obtained as a result of the sequence analysis were compared with the data in GenBank (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov). Phylogenetic analyzes of the obtained sequences were performed using the MEGAX software (22, 23).
Statistical Analysis
Relationships such as whether the positive results were related to age and gender, and whether there was a statistically significant difference, were examined using the chi-square test. The threshold level of statistical significance was taken as p<0.05 [SPSS version 20.0 (Statistical Package for the Social Sciences-SPSS, IBM, Chicago, USA) package software“ chi-square test (X2) (Two-Way Table in Worksheet)” test].
RESULTS
No oocysts could be detected in any of the samples examined by the native-lugol method to search for Cryptosporidium spp. oocysts in stool samples sent to the laboratory for different examinations. After the condensation process with formol-ethyl acetate, the preparations were prepared and examined by Kinyoun’s acid-fast dying method. After the examination, positivity was detected in 4 samples (2.7%) (Figure 1).
As a result of molecular examinations, positivity (Table 3) was detected in 7 samples (4.67%). Four of them are samples that were found positive by microscopic examination (Figure 2). The other 3 had negative results in microscopic examination.
It was determined that 54% of all samples studied were men and 46% were women, and 4 of the positive samples were found in the feces of females and 3 of them were found in male feces. According to the data obtained, no significant relationship was found between gender and positivity (p=3.24).
In this study, 71.43% of the positives were isolated from children in the 0-10 age group (57% especially in the 0-5 age group) and 28.57% from adults aged 24-35, which we can define as the young age group. Cryptosporidium has not been found in any of the individuals over the age of 35. This situation was statistically significant (p<0.05). According to the data obtained, it was understood that the disease was associated with age (Figure 3).
Four of the positive samples were sequenced. As a result of sequencing, 685bp, 746bp, 832bp and 748bp sequences were obtained in the 18S rRNA gene region. Table 4 was obtained as a result of comparing the sequences obtained in this study with other sequences known to be deposited in GenBank. As a result of the Blast and phylogenetic analyzes, the phylogenetic tree given below was formed (Figure 4). According to the data obtained, it was determined that 99.997-100% of the isolates were identical with Cryptosporidium parvum.
While examining the evolutionary history of the sequences we obtained, the “Neighbor-Joining” method was used (24). The optimal tree is shown with length=0.59990219. The percentage of replicated (1000 copies) trees associated with the clustered taxon is given together with tree branches in the bootstrap test (25). Evolutionary distance was calculated using the “Maximum Composite Likelihood” method (26) and units of base numbers per region. This analysis includes 28 nucleotide sequences. All ambiguous positions (with double delete option) have been removed for each row pair. A total of 1909 positions were found in the latest data set. Evolutionary analyzes were performed using MEGA X (22, 23).
Sequence data of Cryptosporidium isolates obtained in the study are deposited in GenBank with accession numbers OL621907, OL689399-401.
DISCUSSION
Cryptosporidium species are coccidian protozoa (15) and their sizes vary according to the species and reproduction stages (21). Cryptosporidium species are monoxen parasites and transmission occurs by oral ingestion of fecal oocysts (2, 12). People who live in the same house with infected people, people they have sexual contact with, health workers, veterinarians, people dealing with agriculture and animal husbandry, people traveling to endemic areas and nursery children are at risk. It can also be transmitted to humans from pets, laboratory animals and farm animals. Oocysts are seen in untreated wastewater, surface, and underground waters, as well as in pool waters, especially as a result of fecal contamination of small children’s pools. It has also been reported that contamination can be seen with certain foods consumed, such as sausages, offal, and raw milk, which are prepared by not paying attention to their cleanliness. Respiratory transmission occurs in immunocompromised patients and AIDS patients. In addition, it can be transmitted by carrier hosts such as soil, arthropods and birds (16, 27). As with malaria, there are indications that the spread of cryptosporidiosis across geographic regions is likely related to modes of transmission. Reasons such as suppression of the host’s immune system, low number of oocysts causing infection, the ability of oocysts to remain in the latent phase in the external environment for a long time (for months at 20 °C) and to be resistant to many disinfectants, the infectivity of oocysts when excreted from the host, animals as reservoirs for some genotypes are factors that determine the epidemiology of Cryptosporidium (2, 7, 27). Currently, regional studies are carried out to detect cryptosporidiosis in healthy and immunocompromised individuals both in Türkiye and around the world.
When we look at the studies done in the world, it has been reported that cryptosporidiosis is a zoonotic disease seen in all regions with a hot climate except Antarctica (4, 7, 15). Recent studies have focused more on the molecular typing, genotypic properties, methods used for the detection of the parasite and the comparison of these methods, isolation from water resources and ecological environment, its effect on epidemics, sanitation or ways of protection etc. rather than the incidence of Cryptosporidium. In order to examine the zoonotic potential of Cryptosporidium in the Netherlands, 70% of C. hominis, 19% of C. parvum, 10% of both combinations and 1% of C. felis isolates were detected from humans and 100% C. parvum isolates from cattle by genotyping from infected human and bovine feces (28). In a study conducted in environmental water samples in Germany, Cryptosporidium was detected at a rate of 30.4% by IFA method, 41.9% by Nested PCR, and 43.6% by LAMP method (27).
There are many studies conducted in Türkiye on human feces with diarrhea. In the examinations made in the Mediterranean Region, Cryptosporidium positivity was reported at a rate of 5.3% by staining method, 10.6% with ELISA method in Adana (7), in another study, it was 1.3% by direct examination method, 5.2% by staining method and 24% by ELISA method (16).
In studies conducted in the Eastern Anatolia Region, one study reported a Cryptosporidium positivity rate of 2.2% (11), while another study determined it to be 20% (13). In patients with chronic renal failure, the positivity rate was 32%, and in healthy individuals, it was 3.3% (10). In a study conducted in Ağrı, Cryptosporidium spp. was positive in 7 cases (3.80%) and identified as C. parvum, belonging to the IId subtype family (9). In the researches carried out in the Aegean Region, Cryptosporidium positivity was reported rate of 3.6% with the direct view method, 4.4% with the painting method in Afyonkarahisar (18), 2.7% by staining method and 3.4% by ELISA method in Kütahya (12). In the studies carried out in the South East Anatolian Region, the rate was 3.2% with the modified acid-fast staining method and 5.8% with the ELISA method in Diyarbakır (15), in another study conducted in the same city, it was 3% with the dyeing method and 4% with the ELISA method (2). The Central Anatolia, Cryptosporidium positivity was reported 5.6% in a study conducted in Ankara (20), in another study at the rate of 0% with the direct view method, 1% with the painting method and 4% with the DFA method in Sivas (3). Studies in the Marmara Region, Cryptosporidium positivity was reported 2.1% of dialysis patients with end stage renal disease (17).
In this study, diarrheal stool samples of 150 people (69F/81M) from different age groups (0-87) who applied to a private hospital in Denizli city center were examined. In the examined fecal samples of patients with diarrhea, no parasites were detected through direct microscopic examination. Using the Kinyoun acid-fast staining method, Cryptosporidium spp. was identified in 2.7% (n=4) of the samples, while Nested PCR detected it in 4.67% (n=7) of the samples. The four positive samples were sequenced using primers that amplify the 18S rRNA gene region. The sequencing results identified the isolates as C. parvum. These results show compatibility with previous studies in terms of prevalence values and differences in results between the applied methods and the detected species.
In a study, Cryptosporidium was detected in adults older than 20 years of age with an incidence of 1.25% and in those younger than 20 years of age with an incidence of 17.8%. Within these data, cryptosporidiosis was largely recorded as a pediatric disease (9, 29). In another study, it was reported that the vast majority (80%) of human cases occurred in children aged 0-9 years (28).
In this study, the majority of the samples detected with cryptosporidiosis belong to children in the 0-10 age group (57% especially in the 0-5 age group). This rate has an incidence of 71.43% among positives. Other positive samples belong to adults aged 24-35 with a rate of 28.57%. No oocyst was detected in any of the individuals over the age of 35. Of the studied samples, 54% belonged to male individuals and 46% to female individuals. These results are in agreement with other studies.
It has been observed that Cryptosporidium species have a very high incidence among parasite species isolated from large epidemics (29), environmental waters (14, 27), and rural areas where well water is used as drinking water (5, 6, 9, 13). It has been determined that Cryptosporidium species can easily pass through the filters of the water processed in the treatment plants before being used in the city network (14, 27). It is stated that Cryptosporidium species are resistant to many disinfectants. In addition, the presence of heavy metals pumping carriers of the species supports its ability to survive (30).
The fact that the aforementioned protozoan, which threatens both human and environmental life, was identified as an infectious agent in our study, the inadequacy of drugs used in the treatment of other coccidian protozoa in the treatment of cryptosporidiosis, effective treatment protocols against Cryptosporidium infections have not yet been established (30) once again reveals the seriousness of the situation we are facing.
CONCLUSION
For this reason, Cryptosporidium species should be added to the fecal indicator organisms, which are among the water quality parameters applied in rural-urban basins. Considering the fecal-oral contamination, care should be taken not to irrigate agricultural products with unfiltered water and sewage mixing water. It is necessary to inform the treatment water facilities and municipal authorities on the subject and to support the studies on the eradication process. Sanitation should be given importance in order to contribute to the economy of both the country and the world, minimize health expenses, and most importantly, to protect public health. In order to ensure personal hygiene and protect against infections, individuals should be made aware, and health policies that improve environmental factors should be developed and implemented.
*Acknowledgments
This study was summarized from the same titled PhD thesis.
We would like to thank Denizli Tekden Hospital for providing the materials.
*Ethics